I loved the hat rule.
As a teacher it was a great rule – it was so easy to tell which students were not in compliance – “Hey, take off your hat!” What was also great about it was that if a student continued to be non-compliant, I didn’t really have to deal with it. I would just forward the issue on to the vice-principal of the school for them to deal with. What a great system!
Of course there were debates at staff meetings about whether hoodies were hats, what about toques in winter, or if students were outside but participating in a course if the hat rule still applied. Really, it seemed like everyone on staff liked the hat rule.
Once I became a vice-principal I started to like the hat rule less. All of the sudden all these teachers were referring names of students to me they saw wearing hats. Other staff members were getting in confrontations with students over hats. And the initial reaction I was having with students was not “Good Morning” but “Take off your hat”.
This is not a post about appropriate dress nor am I trying to elicit responses about how much better it would be if students respected authority like we romanticize they used to do. It is not really about hats at all.
We love things that are simple to think about. I was recently giving a talk about technology and about how messy it is. Giving students the same technology is not the answer, nor is there any real prescription about how much technology they should be using or the kinds of tools they should be using. It is messy.
And this messiness can create anxiety for all of us. We like things that are simple to think about.
And technology, like many things in education is not simple. There are no easy right and wrong answers. There are multiple approaches that can be effective. The same can be said for literacy instruction, supporting aboriginal students or building a vibrant arts program.
I loved the hat rule because it was simple. It was easy to tell which students were in compliance. If I walked through the halls and no students were wearing hats, I could have a sense of accomplishment that I was making a difference.
It is not as easy to walk through the halls of a school and know if all students are learning or being successful.
In retrospect, we spent a lot of time talking about hats at staff meetings – I wonder what it would have been like if we spent the time dedicated to “no kids will wear hats” instead dedicated to talking about “all kids will be successful”.
We would love simple answers in education and unfortunately we selected an occupation that is full of messy, tricky and nuanced challenges.
As I said, I am not trying to pick on those of you who love a hat-free building. Having some simple rules of manners and civility can be good for students and staff. It is important though to think about if we are talking about issues because they are the easy ones rather than the important ones.