We spend a lot of time talking about students and AI. What they are doing with it. What they should be allowed to do with it. Whether they are cheating. Whether it is making them smarter or lazier.
We spend a lot less time asking them.
Recently, a teacher at one of our high schools sent me a note. She had noticed that nearly every voice she heard about AI in education, especially on social media, belonged to an adult. So she did something refreshingly simple. She asked her Grade 11 and 12 students:
What do you wish adults knew about AI?
It was also a lesson in design thinking, which starts with empathy. Understand the people you are designing for before you start solving their problems. Which, now that I write it down, is pretty good advice for school districts writing student AI guidance.
About 75 students responded anonymously. She shared their answers with me in case they sparked a blog post. They did. They also poked a few holes in my thinking, which is the best thing a stack of student responses can do.
“It Really Depends on How We Use It”
The most common theme was unmistakable. Students want us to know that using AI is not the same as cheating. They described using it to study for tests, build practice questions, check their answers, learn languages, and get unstuck. One student explained that AI helps them prepare and makes them mock tests, “but when it comes to assignments, I always do them by myself.” Another put it simply:
“I think adults should understand that using AI doesn’t always mean we’re not putting in effort. It really depends on how we use it.”
A student who has AI write an essay and hands it in is doing something very different from a student who asks AI to explain a chemistry concept three different ways until it finally clicks. Same tool. Very different learning.
I have been thinking a lot lately about productive struggle, and what is still worth the struggle when technology makes so many things easier. These students are a good reminder that not all struggle is created equal. Some struggle is where the learning lives. Some struggle is just a locked door between a kid and the learning.
Knowing the difference is the job.
One response that stood out for me was:
“When I am stuck on a difficult concept or a math problem at night, I can ask an AI to explain it to me five different ways without feeling embarrassed about not getting it the first time.”
I have heard plenty about AI as a personal tutor. This is something more specific. It is about embarrassment. We all know the student who won’t put their hand up. For that student, at 10 o’clock at night, AI is a patient helper that will explain it a sixth time and never sigh.
That doesn’t replace a teacher. But maybe part of the appeal isn’t that AI makes the work easier. Maybe it makes asking for help easier.
Writing Down to Avoid Suspicion
Of all the comments, this is the one I found most disappointing. A student wrote:
“i find it very annoying because i know a lot of people have stopped using big or sophisticated words because they felt like their teachers would assume its ai.”
It wasn’t a lone voice. Another student made the same point about people dropping big words. Another called wrongful accusation “a huge problem that needs to be fixed.” And another raised something I hadn’t considered. Their writing might sound like AI because they have been reading so much AI-generated text without realizing it, and because AI learned to write from humans in the first place.
We spend years telling kids to grow their vocabulary, find their voice, and take risks with language. And now some students tell us they are deliberately dumbing down their writing so nobody suspects them.
That’s a problem.
Academic integrity matters. We need to know the work is theirs. But surely the goal is not for students to prove they are human by writing less well.
A confession. Partway through the responses I hit one that began, “Young people and students often wish adults understood that artificial intelligence is much more than a simple shortcut,” and my first thought was that sounds like a chatbot. Maybe it was. Maybe it was a student who writes well. I have no idea. That’s exactly the point. The suspicion showed up before I had even finished the sentence.
Teach Us
If there was a second theme, it was this. Don’t ban it. Teach us.
One student wrote:
“Instead of banning AI or assuming students are using it to avoid work, adults should teach us how to use it responsibly, question its answers, and recognize when it’s wrong.”
Some version of that showed up again and again. One student argued AI literacy should start in elementary school (we are trying to do this), and not just rules about when to use it, but how it actually works, what the risks are, and how to tell a real photo or video from a fake one.
These were not wide-eyed boosters. Plenty warned that AI is often wrong while sounding completely sure of itself. One described it as “basically telling a convincing lie.” Others raised its environmental cost. They are asking the same hard questions adults are asking.
And since these were entrepreneurship students, one wrote at length about how AI now lets almost anyone build a website, an app, or a business in a matter of days. Then came the kicker. Building the thing is no longer the hard part. The hard part is making people care.
They’re Worried About Us Too
Some of the most pointed responses weren’t about students’ AI use at all. They were about ours.
Adults who believe fake videos. Adults falling for scams. Adults sharing misinformation. One student said their mother uses AI “for way too many tasks.” Another stated something that I know me and many of others in our profession are guilty of at times:
“I wish adults would stop relying on AI for important tasks and hold themselves to the same rules and restrictions they impose on kids.”
Fair. Which brings me to confession number two. I used AI to help draft this post. I do that sometimes, and I note it at the bottom of my posts. But writing about students who are afraid of being accused of using AI, with AI’s help, felt like the moment to say it up top too. Same rules, right?
Being older doesn’t automatically make any of us more digitally literate. Maybe AI literacy is something we learn alongside students rather than something we hand down to them.
“We Are an Experiment”
I increasingly feel this anxiety with parents and students when I talk about AI:
“The lack of what adults know about AI leads me into believing we are an experiment and that concerns me.”
The student went on to describe a generation that seems to know more about AI than many adults do, but has no control over where it is going.
They will live with the consequences of today’s decisions about how AI is built, regulated, and used in schools long after many of us have left the classroom. And most of the conversations about those decisions happen without them. Teachers talking to teachers. Leaders talking to leaders. We write the policies and guidelines, and then we explain them to students.
I wonder if we have that backwards?
Listening Isn’t Agreeing
I don’t want to romanticize any of this. Some students absolutely use AI to dodge the work. A few said so themselves. Some underestimate the risks. We still have to set expectations, teach foundational skills, and help students build the judgment to think for themselves.
Listening doesn’t mean agreeing. It means taking them seriously. And taking them seriously means being willing to discover that some of our assumptions are wrong.
What struck me most is that the students already understand the tension. AI can help them learn. AI can help them skip the learning. They know both are true. That is exactly the conversation we should be having. With them, not just about them.
The Next Question
I am grateful to the teacher who asked such a simple question, and to her students for answering it so honestly.
There is no shortage of adults offering opinions about what AI means for young people. I have contributed more than my share. You are reading one now.
Which leaves me with some homework of my own. We have a district AI Advisory Group. It doesn’t include students. And I’m not sure the answer is simply adding one. A lone student on a committee of adults can easily become a symbol rather than a voice and I don’t think that is actually the right venue. What I’m more interested in is how we hear from students regularly, in ways that actually shape our decisions instead of just decorating them.
I don’t have that figured out yet. But one teacher just showed me a pretty good place to start. Ask a real question. Then listen.
What do you wish adults knew about AI?
It is a question more of us should be asking.
And then the harder one, the one that is really for us.
What are we prepared to change because of what students tell us?










